It could be murder at the Vicarage

The Italian Job - Zola divided opinion during his stay at Upton Park

The Italian Job – Zola divided opinion during his stay at Upton Park

Watford fans are celebrating the appointment of Gianfranco Zola as manager and Gianluca Nani technical director following the sacking of previous boss Sean Dyche by new club owners the Pozzo family. It is the well-liked Italian’s first appointment since himself being ruthlessly dismissed after 20 months in charge of the Hammers. When I say “well-liked” I’m afraid that doesn’t include me. His second season in charge of West Ham was probably the most miserable I’ve seen even including the two most recent relegations in 2003 and 2011. As much as football support is based on the primacy of schadenfreude I can’t but feel sorry for the Hornets.

Appointed in September 2008 as a “unanimous choice” following the resignation of Alan Curbishley, Zola was the surprise package of a shortlist that included current Parma head coach Roberto Donadoni, Croatian boss Slaven Bilic and present Swansea manager Michael Laudrup. Thought to be the favourite pick of Sporting Director Gianluca Nani (in turn brought to the club by Curbishley to oversee foreign transfers)  Zola’s only experience of management was with the Italian under-21 side and he didn’t even possess a full UEFA coaching licence.

Zola’s role was seen as central to “The Project”, a piece of PR fluff that originated from CEO Scott Duxbury, was said to be a method for sustainable growth but in reality was a cover for asset-stripping the club of their most valuable talent. The idea was young players both via the academy and brought in from other clubs were to be developed and sold at a profit while maintaining a Premier League first team. Nani was in charge of this process but appeared to act less like a scout and more an on-the-books agent. Of all the players bought during his reign none were sold at a profit.

Some sympathy most be extended to Zola and assistant manager Steve Clarke even if they were on some of the highest wages in the country despite the clubs losing tens of millions. Duxbury and Nani were engaging in a degradation of the squad with first teamers Bobby Zamora, Matthew Etherington, George McCartney, Anton Ferdinand and Hayden Mullins all sold. Diego Tristan, Radoslav Kovac, Fabio Daprela, Manuel Da Costa and Herita Ilunga were brought in but all proved to be poor substitutes. However, Zola’s decision to reconvene his professional tie with Nani at Vicarage Rd would suggest he was at the very least comfortable with the relationship.

Worst of all, Craig Bellamy, a Premier League striker of real quality (albeit injured for much of his time at West Ham) was replaced by the 19-year-old Savio Nsereko, a largely unknown striker from Germany of Ugandan parentage in a deal laughably said to be £9million but probably closer to £500,000. The poor lad made just one start for the club, never scored, suffered mocking for a lack of ability on the training ground and was last seen on loan at a minor Romanian club suffering from “personal problems”.

Duxbury has been linked with an administrative role at Vicarage Rd. A solicitor brought to the club by former Chairman Terry Brown he was the man who lied to the Premier League over the Carlos Tevez affair. He also forced Curbishley to resign by selling players from under him before being admonished by a judge for taking falsified transfer requests at Curbishley’s subsequent tribunal – a case the manager won. Although not entirely down to him losses incurred by the club for the two incidents total over £30m. Following the collapse of the Iceland banking system and subsequent disappearance of owner Björgólfur Guðmundsson, the club fell into the hands of Duxbury whom I’m led to believe by staff I’ve spoken with treated the place as a personal fiefdom. Perks included a Docklands flat as he rode around town in a club-leased Aston Martin.

Zola’s initial impact at the club was poor. Changing from Curbishley’s favoured 4-4-2 formation with two wingers to a Christmas tree affair with little width and two playmakers behind a target-man proved troublesome for the players, not least the midfield three. Too often other sides sat deep, smothered the link between midfield and front three as they exploited space down the flanks with counter-attacks. Zola’s system was pretty to watch but lacked goal threat by relying too much on the lone striker. Had Dean Ashton been fit and firing it could have worked well but with Carlton Cole – not a natural goalscorer – in place games were often tight. Ironically one of Zola’s few successes was getting Cole, a player with enormous talent but fragile self-confidence, to play somewhere close to his potential. His goal in a 1-0 away win at Wigan in the middle of an eight-game unbeaten run promised much for the future and helped propel the side to a ninth-place finish.

Safe from relegation - West ham players celebrate Pic: Terry Land

Safe from relegation – West Ham players celebrate Pic: Terry Land

Unfortunately that was as good as things got. At the start of season 09-10 the club sold defender James Collins to buy attacker Diamanti leaving just promising youngster James Tomkins and hothead Da Costa to partner Matthew Upson in the centre of defence. Worse still, captain and right-back Lucas Neill had left the club with no real replacement leading to winger Julien Faubert playing right-back. Ilunga at left-back forgot all his first season form and the side always looked likely to leak goals. The Project just wasn’t providing the quality and quantity of players required. Youngsters Junior Stanislas and Zavon Hines showed promise but the rigours of regular top flight football were ultimately too much for them. It’s a tribute to Tomkins he seems to have recovered confidence after a gruelling baptism even if Jack Collison’s initial good form has been subsequently hampered by injury.

Although Burnley, Hull and Portsmouth were three of the worst teams seen in the Premier League the side struggled for results. Close games invariably seemed to drift away from us with Zola lacking the ability to wrest wins from tight encounters. Changes of formation from Christmas Tree to diamond then 4-4-2 and back again seemed to make no difference. By Christmas the side were only a place off the bottom with rumours of dressing-room rifts between the Italian-speakers (Valon Behrami, Luis Jimenez, Da Costa and Diamanti were seen as favourites) and the rest.

Honest players such as Scott Parker, Mark Noble and new captain Upson were having to deal with Diamanti and Jimenez for whom defending was optional at best yet seemed to treat the position of the club as something of a joke. That directly reflected the attitude of the a manager who considered himself a coach, had little input in transfer policy and during his 20 months at the club never once watched another side. For Zola, impressing the youngsters in training appeared to be as important as winning games.

In January 2010 everything changed. Porn barons David Sullivan and Gold bought into  the club, took a couple of weeks to have a look around, gave Duxbury the choice of resignation or a hefty court case and set about maintaining the club’s status in the top flight. Clarke insisted the player to keep the club up was Blackburn’s out of form and overweight striker Benni McCarthy. On the 23rd of March a 3-1 home defeat against Wolves was quite simply one of the worst games I’ve seen from a West Ham side. There seemed to be no direction, no leadership on or off the field and no confidence to carry out allotted tasks.

Tensions rose between the owners and management team as they demanded Zola act like a “proper” manager. In turn he snapped and for the first time went to the press complaining of management interference. Hardly surprising as he’d been allowed to do what he liked under the terms of The Project with little sanction.  Subsequent wins against Sunderland and Wigan after finally dropping Diamanti staved off relegation but the board had seen enough. 35 points from a 38 game season was the lowest ever from a side staying up. Zola had won 23 games from his 80 in charge; a success rate of 29 per cent, the worst of any Hammers boss. Two days after the close of the season Brady sacked the Italian during a 10-minute meeting. Frankly, I’m surprised she took that long.


About Terry Land

West Ham supporter, freelance journalist, photographer, gardener and in possession of pink/green political values. Wedded to the idea health and happiness are best enhanced by the consumption of industrial quantities of curry and chocolate...

Posted on July 8, 2012, in West Ham United and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 10 Comments.

  1. SurfaceAgentX2Zero

    I’m shocked to see that ‘The Project’ was first brought to the public’s attention by Jason Burt. A fine journalist who in no way relies on being spoon-fed PR puffs instead of getting off his arse and doing some actual reporting.

    Talking of Duckers, I think you are unfair. I was always astonished just how competent he was. Not many people could spend all day long on a West Ham chat site revealing confidential and forensic details of the various take-over bids and rubbishing G&S and simultaneously conduct a fair and impartial negotiation process in the best interests of his shareholders. I think such multi-tasking skills should be applauded.

  2. Nani’s already talking about a project again…

    “Everyone knows how Gianfranco Zola likes football to be played,” the Watford technical director Gianluca Nani told the club’s official website.

    “I think Watford’s fans can expect an exciting and attacking style from his team. Gianfranco represents this project perfectly.”


    A couple questions:

    “Sporting Director Gianluca Nani (in turn brought to the club by Curbishley to oversee foreign transfers)…” Had the impression Curbishly gave those quotes about bringing in Nani as a face-saving measure.

    “…admonished by a judge for taking falsified transfer requests…” What’s that one about again? That was McCartney, right? That one drove me to a staggeringly pointless e-mail exchange with CEO SD where he revealed himself to be duplicitous & dim-witted in equal measure.

    • 1. Me too. Never at any time did I get the impression Curbishley wanted Nani at the club. No coincidence either for me it was about the time Nani arrived Duxbury started briefing against Curbs via Surfy’s favourite journo.

      2. McCartney and Ferdinand both. Duckers went to the tribunal with a couple of pieces of paper said to be transfer requests from the players concerned. Not widely reported at the time (I couldn’t find a link) but the judge tore into Duckers over it. Had it been a court of law I get the impression he would have been up for perjury and/or fraud…

  3. Terry, I think your assertion that Watford fans are celebrating is a bit misguided. I think most are happy with the takeover, as the Pozzo family seem to run football clubs in Italy and Spain quite well, promoting the development of youth which is always part of the Watford model. The sacking of Dyche, appointment of Duxbury and Nani have been less well received, and the arrival of Zola is an interesting one, given the previous case of bringing an Italian superstar to Vicarage Road. Two articles that back this up can be found here…

    • Thanks Simon.

      I must confess I took my lead from comments on various newspaper articles and would fully accept they are not a fully representative cross-section of Hornets support. In my defence however, I went to several different sources and positive comment did appear to be all but unanimous.

  4. The sad thing is that even as I read this, I go a bit red because at the time I was still writing The H List and was talking about how “the Project” seemed like a good thing, and what a fine job Zola was doing.

    The notion of buying good young players and moving on older, more expensive types at the height of their value seemed like a decent enough idea – except that in retrospect it was asset stripping by another name.

    I re-read The H List summary of Zola (written in June 2009) and I was vocal in my praise, hailing him for the development of players like Cole and Collison and commending him for making us less dull than we were under the unloved Curbishley.

    Quite possibly the most stark reminder for West Ham fans in recent times to be careful what you wish for.

    (In my defence I hated Duxbury though – he’s the real problem for Watford fans to be cocncerned about)

  5. SurfaceAgentX2Zero

    HHS – I think many of us were guilty of loving the ‘lil fellah for a while.

    To be fair to him, it couldn’t possibly have been a worse decision to keep him on and see how he went without the Machiavellian Duxbury pulling his strings.

    However, given the presence of the oleagenous one, I fear the worst for Hornets fans, with whom I have no particular gripe at all.

  6. I think like many I was taken in by Zola in the first year although there was a nagging doubt about his experience. Like you, the 2009/10 was incredibly painful, probably because I had such high expectations which Zola did not dampen. Remember Jiminez our saviour and then selling Collins. It set the foundation for our relegation the following year

  7. For a high brow oppinion, he looks like a chimp as well.

    Am i remembering wrong but all this he kept us up, were we not 5th when he took over?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: